The APL is the professional association of prison lawyers in England and Wales
Judgement Archive
13 Nov 2026 McDowell [2026] EWHC 2869 (Admin) Decision under s50 Mental Health Act 1983 to notify SSJ that patient could be returned to prison not unlawful.
12 Nov 2026 Seed [2026] EWHC 2910 (Admin) Departure from UAL policy lawful. Yamin [2026] EWHC 2838 (Admin) Adjournment lawful. Art 5 not apply in determinate cases.
30 Oct 2026 O’Leary v Parole Board [2026] EWHC 2773 (Admin) Parole Board decision unlawful because it failed to engage with key factual disputes.
22 Sep 2026 Stanton v UK A disappointing judgment about delay in providing accommodation for release. At least it was accepted that delay must not be systemic or unreasonable.
15 Sep 2026 Newlove [2026] EWHC 2357 (Admin) Important consideration of procedure where lifer wants variation of licence conditions.
03 Aug 2026 Jama 2026 EWHC 2045 (Admin) Refusal to hold an oral hearing re cat A review lawful
01 Jul 2026 Goldsmith [2026] EWHC 1626 (Admin)
12 Jun 2026 Faraj [2026] EWHC 1370 (Admin) Parole Board has jurisdiction to extend time for an application to set aside decision.
04 May 2026 Murcott [2026] EWCA Civ 436 High Court had correctly concluded that no grounds for JR of refusal to transfer to open conditions.
27 Apr 2026 Thakrar [2026] EWCA Civ 503 Continued use of Closed Supervision did not violate human rights
15 Apr 2026 Hossain [2026] EWHC 862 (Admin) Decision to extend exclusion zone in licence was not unlawful.
12 Mar 2026 Gambrah v The Director of HMP Thameside [2026] EWHC 523 (Admin) Prison Service acted unlawfully by delaying release despite court order
11 Mar 2026 Ahmed Sabbagh-Perry [2026] EWHC 501 Nothing unlawful in decisions regarding categorisation and HDC relying on immigration status.
29 Jan 2026 Ford [2026] EWHC 131 Parole Board acted unlawfully by failing to hold an oral hearing.
20 Jan 2026 R (Mahmod) [2025] EWHC 3444 (Admin) Policy of pre-tariff sifts was rational.
23 Dec 2025 Heaton [2025] EWHC 3375 (Admin) Licence conditions lawful even though they prevented prisoner returning home.
09 Dec 2025 Beggs [2025] CSOH 112 Parcel policy did not discriminate against prisoners who did not come from Scotland.
09 Dec 2025 Williams [2025] EWHC 3183 (Admin) Parole Board decision not unlawful.
01 Dec 2025 Merrington [2025] EWHC 3025 (Admin) SSJ rejection of recommendation for open conditions lawful
26 Nov 2025 Taylor v SSJ [2025] EWHC 3007SSJ entitled to impose licence conditions on Extended Prisoner without decision of the Parole Board where prisoner automatically released.
03 Nov 2025 Malik [2025] EWHC 2772 (Admin) Refusal to hold an oral hearing before the Parole Board was unlawful.
13 Oct 2025 R (Quilligan) v SSJ [2025] EWHC 2592 Recall of prisoner unreasonable. Also it was unreasonable to fail to quash the recall in light of the findings of the Parole Board.
10 Oct 2025 R (Charles Smith) v SSJ [2025] EWHC 2560 Decision regarding open conditions was not irrational
11 Aug 2025 Smith AC-2024-LDS-000039-89 Final Judgment – Two claims dealt with in the same hearing, the 1st challenge to SOS refusing to accept PB recommendation, the 2nd a challenge to refusal to grant oral hearing on a Cat A review.Both unsuccessful.
26 Jun 2025 Kane Vs Parole Board for England and Wales – A challenge to the decision of the Parole Board wherein no direction for release was made. Predicated mainly on the submission that there was a mistake of fact. Claim dismissed.
19 Jun 2025 R(Nguyen) v Secretary of State for Justice [2025] EWHC 2024 (Admin) – unsuccessful JR of a decision to recall a life sentenced prisoner. C was previously recalled on allegations of breaching his alcohol monitoring tag. The Parole Board held that his recall was unlawful and directed his release.
26 Mar 2025 R (on the application of Neophytou) v Governor of Berwyn Prison – Court of appealheld that a prison governor did not have power to refuse to submit a request for early release on health grounds to the Secretary of State other than in a clear case where the criteria for granting early release were not met.